Love and Marriage by solvent90 (PG)

[hlbr.livejournal.com]

Fandom: JANE AUSTEN (MANSFIELD PARK)
Pairing: Fanny Price/Henry Crawford with a side of Mary Crawford/Edmund Bertram
Length: 3200 words
Author on LJ: solvent90
Author Website: solvent90's other stories at yuletide, and solvent90's fic tag.
Why this must be read:

This is an excellent, well written story, where the silences are almost as important as the things said. A powerful look at what may have been, it's not a happy story, but a necessary one. It's honest to a fault, and gives a new perspective on the canon characters. Definitively a different look at the Fanny accepts Henry scenario. It has a very good narrative voice, which makes for a quick, pleasant read.

Excerpt:

"I am afraid your cousin's is not quite a marriage of true minds, my dear," he said.

Love and Marriage

Comments

[maidenjedi]

I have to tell you thank you for the Fanny/Henry recs. It's the "pairing that got away" for me in JA! :-)

[hlbr.livejournal.com]

No prob. That what-if (What if Fanny would've said yes to Henry.) is one that jumps out from the book at a first read. I definitively wanted that to be the end in MP, even though I saw why JA would not go for it. :D So I indulged myself with these two.

This is the last Fanny/Henry that I will rec, but I've a couple more MP fics. Truly, for such small amount of people writing it, there's a lot of excellent fic out there.

[maidenjedi]

Is there a reliable way to locate Fanny/Henry or MP stories without digging through a ton of P&P fics?

I'm relatively unfamiliar with the JA fic sites; I rely on Yuletide for my fix :-(

[hlbr.livejournal.com]

Uhm, there's various ways you can go about it.

One is to look for it in the Derbyshire Writers' Guild (). The search engine there (http://www.austen.com/toc/search.php) is pretty good, and you can restrict the search by book. Other fanfiction sites are forums or static sites made by html pages, and there's no quick way to search them by book, I'm afraid.

Other sites are A Happy Assembly Forum (http://meryton.com/aha/index.php), 50 Miles of Good Road Forum (http://scotch-and-sirens.waw.pl/index.php), and Austen Interlude (http://austeninterlude.org/). (Of the top of my head; there are more.) The only way to find stuff this way is to search posts as you would any other forum, but it's a little bothersome, or post asking if anyone knows of any MP fics. Or trawl the stories' subforum. (The book the ff is based on is usually in the title. If it doesn't say anything, it's probably P&P.)

The other, more general way, is to search through the Jane Austen Fanfiction Index (http://www.jaffindex.com/ff_login.php). Here you will find stories no matter where they're archived, if the author has consented to be listed. You can use the search engine to look for stories by a particular book, or by theme, type or trope, etc. (Though if you're not used to this particular fandom, the tropes might seem a little random and alien.) Here there are a password and username you can use (case sensitive): Username: SASReader Password: Edinburgh (The passwords are site based--I gave you 50 Miles' adult one, because I think you're over 18, right?) If you need help using it, just contact me.

[hlbr.livejournal.com]

Heh, I forgot, the forums (AHA and 50Miles) are closed. You have to be a member to read. You will run into this problem following links from JAFF Index, too, though, and becoming a member is not really that much of a hassle, so I would do it if I were you.

(It is a hassle for reccing though. *grumbles*)

Also, from the JAFF Index you will see broken links to a site called the Hyacinth Gardens. That's a big forum, and it's down. It should be up soon, though.

[maidenjedi]

Thank you - this is a big help!

(And yup, I'm over 18...for about eleven years now, lol)

Yay!

[elizabeth-hoot.livejournal.com]

What a brilliant take on this most popular of alternate pairings - I love it! While the author does, so to speak, take up the offer Austen makes in MP, she doesn't try and make it bunny rabbits and rainbows, either, as so many do. She doesn't blacken anybody, and she doesn't whitewash them either. There's no sense that this is about any of the parties being unworthy of the other, that they're all unhappy because Henry and Mary are selfish sophisticates or, alternatively, Fanny and Edmund are dull and censorious - rather, she shows how they're genuinely ill-suited.

Fashionable London life is oppressive and destructive for Fanny - but it's hard not to feel that provincial seclusion is just as oppressive, just as destructive, for Mary. Fanny's pale, faded existence is heartbreaking - yet no more than this:

Henry caught Mary's dark eyes darted at him just then, and could not help the twist of his smile; she lifted her brows in response and, in that moment, was his sister again.

But then, I've always thought the Henry-Mary dynamic the most compelling relationship in MP.

Here, it's quiet, desperate, everyday tragedy - not what you'd find in Austen, but what I think she foresaw for them in MP, and perhaps why she didn't go there.

Re: Yay!

[hlbr.livejournal.com]

But then, I've always thought the Henry-Mary dynamic the most compelling relationship in MP.

Don't give people ideas. ;)

Without kidding, I like this story very much; and I specially like the juxtaposition with Everingham. Two very different takes on a situation that comes to anyone who reads MP, really.

Indeed this story is not what one would find in Austen... at least not in central stage. (As background... I can think of a couple or two, that while are not identical to F/H or M/E, fill the domestic tragedy bill just right.)

Re: Yay!

[elizabeth-hoot.livejournal.com]

Oh, that's been done already, of course. And published, I believe. They need no help from me!

The juxtaposition with Everingham does, I think, make them both stand out all the more - their similarities only throw the differences into sharper relief.

Oh, that kind of thing is definitely in the background, of course! (*Thinks of Eliza Brandon*) I meant that, rather, Austen would hardly have chosen to write a novel about two quasi-failed marriages. A little too much guilt and misery for her, methinks!

Re: Yay!

[hlbr.livejournal.com]

Oh, that's been done already, of course. And published, I believe. They need no help from me!

Really? o_O What's the title?

Wait, we are talking incest, right?