Fandom: CSI
Pairing: Grissom/Sara
Author on LJ:
always_winterAuthor Website: http://www.geocities.com/ofmoonbeams/Why this must be read:"Dying is easy. Comedy is hard."
--Apocryphal Shakespearean actorThe above statement is especially true when it comes to writing fics based on shows that don't tend towards comedy in the first place. Yes, various CSI episodes might have funny moments and snerk-worthy dialogue, but unlike (for example) The X Files, the show hasn't aired an episode that was deliberately comedic from beginning to end. That makes it much harder for an author to find and sustain a comic tone that doesn't create a fingernails-on-a-chalkboard cognitive dissonance.
Wintertime took a big risk with this story, which has a scenario (a game of Truth or Dare) that has produced cringe-worthy results when used by other writers. It works, though, mostly because even with some slight comic exaggeration, everyone stays very much in character. In fact, a lot of the funny comes from simple observations of what the characters are like:
When Greg wanted something, he looked needy. When Catherine wanted something, she looked dangerous, as if she might hold you down and force you to give it to her. In addition, Wintertime has created a wonderful narrative voice for Grissom, who has apparently created a whole set of rules for how to preserve his privacy and maintain that infamous emotional distance:
A never-fail rule for dealing with CSI personnel - - if you send a plant to a young woman and tell her that she makes you notice beauty, then be prepared to deal with everyone thinking that you harbor a deep-seated romantic love for her. Also, be prepared to be annoyed when you realize that they’re right, and you’re an idiot.Then, there are the bits with the security cameras, the Jenga game, Warrick's Grissom impression, the various acts of petty revenge...
Oh, heck with it. Go. Read. Enjoy.
Also, laugh while you can, because we're heading into much darker territory with the next couple of recs.
How to Have a Social Life Without Really Trying