Fandom: MAGNIFICENT SEVEN
Pairing: None, gen
Length: novel
Author on LJ: not - that I know of
Author Website: much of it is at blackraptor
Why this must be read:
In keeping with my MOMA theme (this year's awards winners), this won - more than deservedly - as the best gen story. I will admit upfront that I am amazed that nothing by the Cohorts has been mentioned on Crack_van before. They don't have a vast oeuvre, but what they have is outstanding.
To be straight - I don't write gen, not intentionally (sometimes things happen) and there aren't many stories that actually make me regret that, but everything I've read by these guys and BMP has been so good, so well-written in terms of plot and characterization and the dynamics of the team collectively and in smaller groups, that I know I would fail. The talent these gen writers is stunning.
In terms specific to "Reality Check", there's an extra-added, sort of 'meta' level of writing going on. For those of us who have read for a while in this fandom, it's a wonderful . . . commentary on the elaborate alternative universes that this fandom has engendered, and on the fanon some of these universes have produced, details that are so consistent that people who haven't seen the show itself are actually surprised to discover that there's no canon for the consistent qualities at all! There's no cruelty in the presentation, though, and there's a balance of humor and seriousness that marked the actual episodes themselves. The authors do a brilliant weaving of Old West, ATF, Little Britches, and the creation of a newer, modern AU, while keeping the characters consistent and in-character to the canon - and to the fanon, oddly, which is what's brilliant. At the same time, they resolve several situations in several of the universes in a way that would make the writers of most television science fiction proud.
This award winner is one I back 100% - well and truly earned!
And here's the real thing - but it is wonderfully, wickedly, delightfully, long!!!!!
Reality Check by the CohortsPS - The runners-up in this category (which is hard to be because you have to score within five points of the winner's score - and yes, there are 2 here, which tells you have close it was) are:
"Breathe" by BMP and
"So Easy to Kill" by - The Cohorts!